Best Crib Mattresses in 2022

Last update: November 14, 2022

Can my baby sleep on a foam mattress?

Foam mattresses are becoming increasingly popular for babies, as they offer a variety of benefits. Foam mattresses are softer than traditional mattresses, which can provide a more comfortable sleeping surface for your baby. They are also more lightweight and easier to move than traditional mattresses, making them a good choice for parents who plan on traveling with their baby. Additionally, foam mattresses are typically more affordable than traditional mattresses.

Do all mattresses fit cribs?

Most mattresses will fit into a crib, but there are a few things you need to take into account. The size of the mattress is the most important factor, as you need to make sure it is not too big or too small for the crib. The thickness of the mattress is also important, as you need to make sure it is not too thick or too thin. You also need to make sure the mattress is firm enough to support your baby.

How can I make my crib more comfortable?

If you want to make your crib more comfortable, there are a few things you can do. You can add a mattress topper to make the mattress softer, or you can add a blanket or quilt to make the bedding warmer. You can also add a pillow to make the headboard more comfortable.

How do I choose a crib mattress?


Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Toddler Bed and Next Stage Baby Crib Mattress with Waterproof Bamboo Cover- 27.5 inches x 52 inches x 5.5 inches Review:


My five-year-old continues to snooze in a toddler bed. Since the day he was born, he has slept on the mattress made of crackly plastic. I knew he needed a new mattress when he started choosing to sleep on the floor because it was "more comfy." This one came to me by chance.To allow it to begin expanding so that he could use it the following night, we unrolled and unsealed it one evening. It didn't smell particularly strong. It was a tight fit when we put his crib sheet on it. Although the sheets all fit and I loved that he wouldn't get books and toys lost in the gaps, this mattress looks to be a BIT bigger than the creaky ones from that huge box store.I almost wanted to sleep on it because it seems so cozy. Sadly, I'm not a little child. I can confirm that he no longer chooses to sleep on the floor. We were so pleased with the improvement that we went back and purchased another for his 3-year-old brother's bed.The mattress cover's ability to repel water has not been rigorously tested. The average 3-year-old wears a nighttime diaper, whereas a 5-year-old has a cotton pad that goes under his blankets in case of any mishaps that might occur at that age. I'm assuming it works, but we're happy to continue using the pads we were using with the old, creaky mattress in order to keep this one doubly safe.



Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System, Firm Side for Baby and Soft Side for Toddler - 100% Cotton Cover Review:


I can't comment to how the mattress is actually being used just yet because our little girl hasn't yet arrived. The keyboard warriors out there may have put some disgruntled parents in our shoes, so I'd like to attempt to help them out. We were on the verge of buying a few mattresses when we saw some ominous warnings like "THIS MATRESS IS NOT FOR INFANTS SIDS SIDS SIDS DEATH SCARY AHHHHH!" Even though the reviewer's numerous spelling errors make it clear they are an idiot, you can't help but worry that you might unintentionally buy a marshmallow mattress that would cause your infant to suffocate itself, so you move on to the next one. I whittled down a list of three options after growing weary of my wife's frustration during our quest and informed her we would choose one of them and that would be it. She claimed she chose this because I had previously considered it as one of the initial options she almost chose, and she was happy to find that I had also accepted it. The unasked-for, unqualified opinions about the mattress being too soft for infants had scared her away.I'm a fan of science. an engineer My entire life is devoted to materials science. Before deciding to put my child on it, I wanted to test this out a bit. This mattress began to take shape as soon as I removed it from the vacuum sealer. It perfectly filled the crib, which was a tremendous relief. The mattress didn't even flinch when I put three full diaper boxes on their sides, roughly the same square area as a young toddler. I conducted this experiment in an attempt to quantify the mattress's sinkage, but it was so minimal that I was unable to measure it using a tape measure. I measured the weight of the stack of boxes, and it was 15.2 lbs., which is more than double the weight of the typical baby. Perhaps you're thinking that this sounds too challenging. I am unsure of how my baby will react to it, but I know that I will feel secure knowing that the mattress is not at all soft enough to worry about smothering. Don't let the diagnosis provided by the Amazon Pediatricians scare you away. When their hand sinks into the mattress, these folks complain and rush to their computer, exerting ten times the effort that a tiny child would. They have good intentions, I'm sure, but they lack intelligence and are unquestionably incorrect. It's wise to exercise skepticism and avoid naively believing any old manufacturer, but I can attest that this one appears to be a quality product right out of the box.



Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Orthopedic Style Crib Mattress | Eco-Friendly Foam with Ultra-Soft Organic Waterproof Hypoallergenic Cotton Cover – 51.63” x 27.25” x 6” Review:


I can't speak for the baby because he hasn't arrived yet, but I LOVE it. To replace a Simmons Beautyrest Sleepy Beginnings mattress, I got this one. When the Simmons arrived, it looked to bunch up way too much, and the sides weren't firm. I had originally desired a coil mattress since I felt they were more supportive and had a lower temperature. I returned the mattress since I needed a nice firm mattress and I'm terrified of SIDS. Later, after doing more research and finding the Colgate on so many top mattress websites, I decided to give it a try. It's incredible! Definitely light, yet incredibly firm! No area of the mattress looks less firm than the others after being placed in the crib. It perfectly matched my Davinci crib. The corners also matched up perfectly without any gaps. After the sheet is on, the mattress doesn't bunch up much and seems cool and light. Its use of organic materials is fantastic. Knowing that my baby won't be exposed to harmful pollutants makes me feel better. Although it claims to be waterproof, I'm a little concerned about how effective a mattress protector will be. This is definitely something I would advise.



Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress with Waterproof Cover - 27.5 inches x 52 inches x 4.75 inches Review:


I am a twin mom. Life is costly. I wanted the greatest value possible when I required new mattresses for their toddler beds. That's it. Each of my original crib mattresses cost more than $150. Due to the prematurity and sensitive skin of my twins, I wanted to choose natural or organic products. Three years later, they are top tiles for height and weight without any problems. I believe that the "greatest mattress" would allow me to unwind a little.When the mattresses did, I had to unroll them. Nothing major. They grew in a half-hour. The quality of the exterior coating was the first great thing I observed. FANTASTIC. Along with being my favorite color, gray is also strong but plush. I spent LESS on these 2 mattresses than I did on ONE when my children were newborns, so please understand that. This is of significantly higher quality. Period.Second, my daughters slept soundly all night. This may not be a major deal for everyone. This is a MASSIVE issue for a mother of four children, two of which are 2.5-year-old twins who DO NOT sleep through the night. Even though I had to check on them, I discovered them dozing off in their beds. I went back to sleep after my heart had melted. Unbeatable night after night.An unexpected HUGE positive comes next. My daughters would have bed head for three years. I experimented with everything, including oils, conditioners, satin sheets, unique hairbrushes, and haircuts. People in the store would remark on how bad the bedhead on my girls was. I gave up after hearing from family that "they will grow out of it." In the hopes of waking up to a miracle, I continued applying conditioner, oils, and brushing their hair. Until my daughters awoke from this mattress, I didn't. CELEBRATE THE LORD. I'm not sure if the mattress is to blame or if angels arrived to straighten their hair that night. You select that option.I adore how my daughters will swaddle themselves in their blankets, lay their heads down, and nod out. They must be sleeping comfortably if they have great hair when they wake up. We appreciate Milliard's commitment to quality and quick shipping. I can't express how much you've helped me in this review.



Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer Cover Review:


I was cautiously optimistic after reading the other reviews of this mattress. In order to guarantee the reader learns how to get the most out of this fantastic product, I've compiled the information I discovered in the reviews together with my personal experience. The majority of concerns were about the mattress expanding and having a chemical odor. First, as you unwrap it, take care to only cut the box and plastic shipping bag and not the mattress or mattress cover. Next, take off the mattress cover in a room with good ventilation. If you can, open a window. On a hard, level surface, let the mattress expand for at least 48 hours before flipping it over after the first 24 hours. If any corner does not rise or appears to be crumpled, pound, fluff, massage, knead, etc. that corner until it is expanded and full. We let it to sit out for such a long time that the chemical scent was gone for us. Put the mattress back in the mattress cover after it has fully expanded, cover it with a sheet, and set it in your crib. The mattress fit into our two Graco Lauren Convertible Cribs easily and snuggly. After about 10 minutes of settling, there was nothing between the crib slats and the mattress. See my photos to get a sense of how well the fit is. The mattress's final dimensions are 52"x28"x5". In summary, the other bad reviews complained about a scent, an improper expansion, and an uncomfortable fit. This is all resolved by taking off the cover and allowing the item to expand/air out for 48 hours. Due to the nature of the material, there will ALWAYS be some heat diffusion issues with foam, but other than that, I would much rather have it than a creaky, uncomfortable mattress. Don't be turned off by people who didn't take the effort to get their mattress in the greatest possible shape; my newborn baby is already sleeping well on his new foam mattress. Good fortune!



Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress | Waterproof | Lightweight | GREENGUARD Gold Certified (Natural/Non-Toxic) Review:


When I started looking for a crib mattress, I wanted something affordable, but every mattress I considered had unfavorable ratings. Although there were conflicting reviews and a really reasonable price point, I eventually had to choose, and I'm so delighted that I went with this mattress. Since she was three months old, my daughter, who is now almost seven months old, has only ever slept on this. When the infant moved around, some of the reviews claimed that it produced a lot of noise, however I have not noticed any sounds. The mattress is firm, which I really appreciate. It is a really solid, sturdy mattress, and I believe it keeps her supported. This mattress should last us to the toddler bed stage. This is unquestionably a great mattress to choose if you're looking for one that is affordable and excellent. Do not be swayed by unfavorable evaluations. With this mattress, I am quite impressed.



hiccapop Foldable Safe Lift Universal Crib Wedge for Baby Mattress and Sleep Review:


For the cribs of my twin children, I bought two of these. They were playing in the rock band before to this. I think it's a smooth transition from the rock and play's raised and snug position. I saw some reviews where things were sliding down, but I haven't experienced that. After some time, my children do start to slide down more in the middle of the bed, but I believe it will always happen when you have them resting at an elevated slant. The only issue I have with it is that I think the seam they lay on at the bottom of the ramp is quite difficult. To me, it would feel like lying on a pencil or another hard object on your back. I got a nice blanket and wrapped it around the lollipops before covering both of them with a sheet. That contributes to making it softer. Since I've only used it for a few nights and the girls are waking up more frequently, I can't say for sure how well it will help them move to their crib, but I believe it will happen regardless. When I lay my daughters down on this, they both spew up horribly, yet neither of them moans. When I lay them flat on their backs after they have eaten, they become very unhappy. That indicates to me that they are reasonably happy with this.



Dream On Me 3" Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress, White Review:


The proportions of this product are the first thing I want to draw attention to. You see, I was a little perplexed because they advertise this mattress to go with the crib that I purchased, the Dream on Me 3 in 1 Aden Convertible Mini Crib. The advertised dimensions of this mattress are 38 x 24 x 3 inches. Now, the crib's instructions warned me not to use it with a mattress that was thicker than 2 inches. In order to be sure, I measured the mattress TWICE and came up with the following measurements: 37 x 24 x 2. This is advantageous because the measurements comply with crib requirements, although it did lead to some uncertainty. To the mattress now. I read some reviews before buying this that complained about how difficult it is. Well, it is described as being EXTRA FIRM. Contrary to what some other reviewers have said, it is not "hard as a rock." Additionally, keep in mind that infants should sleep on firmer mattresses to avoid SIDS. What your baby will and won't like is also something you cannot foresee. It's not a guarantee that your kid won't like the hardness just because you don't. The bed is a firm one. But I think the increased firmness was intended to emphasize this. Since my due date is still seven weeks away, I haven't yet used the mattress. But I took a lot of time pressing it and allowing my 18-month-old toddler walk on it. I am quite happy so far. Although the stiffness of the product doesn't affect ME, I can see how it would bother others, and I still believe some of the complaints I've seen are highly exaggerated, I give it a rating of 4 stars due to the unclear product measurements.



Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight Review:


The mattress for a crib is excellent. Although I was concerned, it is firm without being oppressively so. Since he arrived home from the hospital, my kid, who is almost 6 months old, has been sleeping in his rock and play sleeper next to my bed. Because he is so used to sleeping somewhat elevated in his rock and play sleeper, I was concerned about how he would adjust to sleeping in a crib. He transitioned to a crib beautifully, and I believe the comfort of this mattress played a significant role in that. He snoozes on it all night long. It became noticeably softer when a crib mattress protector cover was applied, so it undoubtedly contributed as well. The only issue I really have is that the mattress was shipped in a plastic cover bag with a lot of tiny holes in it. I'm not sure if this was done on purpose to allow the mattress to breathe or what; but, given that it is a vinyl-covered mattress, I doubt it. When I removed the plastic covering the mattress, it was really unclean; to completely clean it, I used Clorox wipes. The worst aspect was that it had a few tiny holes in it around the edge of the mattress. I don't blame the manufacturer because it's a terrific mattress; instead, I attribute this to poor packaging, handling, and quality control at the Amazon warehouse prior to shipping. Do your homework and purchase the mattress elsewhere since it is available at other retailers for roughly the same price. I regret not purchasing it from Walmart right away. I made the decision to keep it since I needed the mattress right away and didn't have the time to go through the hassle of mailing it back, waiting for a refund, and purchasing another one. Again, this is a fantastic crib mattress, and none of this is the fault of the manufacturer, so I'll still give it five stars.



Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress for Baby & Toddler, Water Resistant, Lightweight, Hypoallergenic, Green Guard Gold Certified Review:


Before my son arrived in 2015, I bought this because it had generally positive ratings. I did a lot of study on infant-related topics. For when we visited my parents, we even bought a second, identical one for their nursery. Other reviewers are posting about problems they claim to have encountered, and after reading them, I'm a little uneasy (mold, a worn-out mattress? However, my kid, who is now 2.5, will be moved to a full bed, and this mattress will be used for baby number two. When we change our sheets each week, I'll pay great attention to the mattress, but so far there have been no issues. Our mattress doesn't frequently get wet, and there are no problems with it falling apart. If there are any changes, we'll update!


How long can a kid sleep in a toddler bed?

Most kids will outgrow a toddler bed between the ages of 2 and 3. However, some kids may need to use a toddler bed until they’re 4 or 5. If your child is still using a toddler bed, it’s probably because they’re not ready to make the switch to a regular bed.

How long can a toddler sleep on a crib mattress?

Most crib mattresses are designed to last for about three years, though some can last up to five years. When your toddler has outgrown their crib, it's time to upgrade to a toddler bed.

How long is a crib mattress good for?

A crib mattress is typically good for around three to five years, though some manufacturers may recommend replacing it sooner. If you notice any sagging or lumpiness in the mattress, it's time for a new one.

How thick should a crib mattress be for a newborn?

A newborn needs a firm mattress to sleep on, and the thickness should be no more than six inches. The mattress should also have a tight-fitting sheet.

Is a 2 stage crib mattress necessary?

Is spring or foam mattress better for babies?

A spring mattress is better for babies because it provides the necessary support for their developing bones and joints. A foam mattress may be more comfortable for adults, but it does not provide the same level of support that a spring mattress does.