Best Baking & Cookie Sheets in 2022

Last update: December 30, 2022

Can you bake cookies just on a cookie sheet?

A cookie sheet, also known as a baking tray, is a flat, rectangular metal pan used for baking cookies, biscuits, and other flat, oven-baked goods. Many types of cookie sheets are available. The most common type is the aluminum cookie sheet, which is inexpensive and easy to clean. However, aluminum cookie sheets can cause cookies to brown unevenly. Nonstick cookie sheets are also available and may help prevent sticking and promote even browning, but they can be more expensive than aluminum cookie sheets.

Can you put 2 cookie sheets in the oven at the same time?

Yes, you can put 2 cookie sheets in the oven at the same time. If you are baking 2 different types of cookies, you may want to put one sheet on the top rack and one sheet on the bottom rack to ensure that both types of cookies bake evenly.

Do cookies cook better on parchment paper?

Parchment paper is ideal for cookies because it prevents them from sticking and makes cleanup a breeze. Parchment also helps cookies cook evenly by absorbing excess heat and promoting even browning.

Do you have to change parchment paper after each batch of cookies?

If you're using parchment paper to bake cookies, you don't need to change it between batches. Parchment paper is heat-resistant and non-stick, so you can reuse it multiple times. Just make sure to keep it clean and free of crumbs.


KITCHENATICS 100% Stainless Steel Wire Cooling and Roasting Rack Fits Small Quarter Sheet Size Baking Pan, Oven Safe, Commercial Quality, Heavy Duty for Cooking, Roasting, Drying, Grilling 8.5" x 12" Review:


I've had terrific luck using the CIA 23304 Masters Collection 12 Inch x 17 Inch Wire Cooling Rack, Chrome Plate Steel recommended by America's Test Kitchen for years, largely as cooling racks. I've never had rust concerns, and they've always cleaned up easy for me with a soapy brush at the sink. They have done an excellent job meeting my needs. Recently, a large project left me short on rack space. These caught my attention as I was looking for more racks, so I decided to give them a shot. How do they compare then? I usually anticipate being disappointed when I do something blind. You may refer to me as a skeptic, but in this particular case I've been pleasantly surprised! These racks are fantastic; they are not in the least bit flimsy, harsh, or anything else that might go wrong with a rack, in my opinion. They fit my half sheets and are bright and strong. There is no reason not to choose the CIA racks if cost is a factor, you plan to use them as cooling racks, and you are prepared to (easily) hand wash them. But these Kitchenatics racks are lovely, and if I had to choose between them for an oven use, I'd choose the stainless.*Kitchenatics 17.91 oz. and CIA 18.52 oz. are both geeky items.



Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets Non-Stick Parchment Paper, 25 Sheet, 4 Count Review:


I use a great deal of parchment paper. I always take a box of these when I prepare anything—cookies, breads, pizza, or anything else. They prevent the baked items from sticking and fit nicely inside a half sheet pan. They are priceless only for that reason alone. They prevent food from adhering to baking sheets and pans. Do it after me. If you have these clever small baking sheets, anything containing cheese or chocolate won't be messy or difficult to remove from the pan. I purchase the enormous rolls, however sometimes it can be difficult to size them to fit your pan. I just assumed I would have to make do with the fact that I always wind up with a sheet that is either too big or too small. I then discovered these and placed my order on Subscribe



USA Pan 1602CR Half Sheet Bakeable Nonstick Cooling Rack, Pan, Metal Review:


Great addition to my kitchen overall. The pan itself appears to be solid, but the first time I used it in a 450 degree oven, after 6 minutes, I heard it make a startling "warp pop." Of course, once it had cooled, everything had straightened up. I didn't hear that, though, as I was cooking a sheet of bacon this morning in a 350 degree oven. The rack worked wonders with the bacon and is wonderful for cooling my homemade breads and muffins. The rack is far less robust, though. After it arrived, I tried to bend it while washing it, but I'm not that strong. But now that I'm aware of this, I've made sure to wash delicately ever since. It turned out to be much simpler than I anticipated to clean up after the mess that was the bacon run. (However, I kind of wished I had an industrial sink for my industrial sized pan. With merely the stream of water, the bacon grease that had accumulated in the pan and then burned to the top was practically removed. On the metal, it did, however, leave a slight discoloration. I'm hoping that quickly dissipates with time. I kept the rack in the pan exactly as it was sent, however I've noticed minor scratches if I move the rack within. They appear to simply rub off, though. So, despite its shortcomings, this set is still a terrific complement to my kitchen and, in my opinion, any kitchen.



Rachael Ray 47425 Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips, Nonstick Cookie Sheets / Baking Sheets - 3 Piece, Gray with Marine Blue Grips Review:


The Rachel Ray Oven Lovin' Nonstick Pan Set is AMAZING. I couldn't have come up with a finer name.They offer me the ideal size option for my oven and culinary needs with their three-piece set, which is just one of the things I love about them.It comes in a three-piece set with a 9x13-inch, a 10x15-inch, and an 11x17-inch pan.They stack inside of one another, taking up less room in my cupboard.They are so adaptable that I have used them for numerous purposes. making biscuits, garlic bread, roasting veggies, baking chicken or other meats that don't need a deep pan for the sauce, and so on...**When I cooked chicken legs in a really hot oven, the skin did stick a little bit, but it was still okay. Most things do not stay to the pans.450 degrees Fahrenheit Oven Safe.Since they are currently truly nonstick, they are simple to clean.A percentage of the money is donated to Yum-O, a nonprofit organization.These have evolved into my "go to" pans for practically all of my oven cooking. I heartily endorse them!



New Star Foodservice 33977 Commercial-Grade 18-Gauge Aluminum Sheet Pan/Bun Pan, 9 2/3" W x 6 2/3" L x 1" H (1/8 size) Review:


I started looking for silicone mats for our tiny, inexpensive baking sheets before deciding I needed new baking sheets, cooling/cooking racks, and mats. I read countless reviews about sheets that rust, absorb water, bend, and lose their form as I searched and searched. Racks that have bad welds, rust, warp, or are simply weak and unable to handle much weight. Mats that smoke and/or release weird scents. I started to doubt my ability to find something trustworthy on Amazon. Before this company, New Star Foodservice, appeared, I changed my search parameters a number of times. I decided to go forward with my purchase after reading the reviews and gradually regaining my trust. These were combined with Hamilton Housewares' sturdy stainless steel racks. I bought two 1/4 sheet sets for our toaster oven, one 1/2 sheet set, and the biggest set that will fit in our standard oven, a 2/3 sheet set.My spouse and I are thrilled! We now have these premium sheets in all these sizes, each with a silicone pad and a cooling/cooking rack. As of now, so nice! Everything is so simple to clean up, and we don't notice any of the several problems other reviewers have mentioned.



Good Cook 13 Inch x 9 Inch Cookie Sheet Review:


This pan is quite amazing for $5! I added this pan to my purchase because I needed a pan and didn't feel like traveling to the store. For $5, I didn't have high hopes, but I'm amazed! In the few instances that I've used it, the nonstick has performed admirably. Additionally, the pan is simple to clean, and according to the sticker, it has a lifetime warranty—which is fantastic for such an inexpensive pan! Expecting a high-quality pan that will last a long time for $5 is unrealistic; you will need to spend more. However, considering how inexpensive it was, it works well if you just need a pan to reach you quickly. Overall, I'm pleasantly surprised with the value for the money! Please select "useful" if this review was at anyway helpful. I'm grateful.



Good Cook Set Of 3 Non-Stick Cookie Sheet Review:


The main problem we encountered after using the cheapest baking pans we could locate was food spilling over the edges and into the oven.These trays, which have a thin lip around the outside of them, do a good job of resolving that.The pans have a wonderful nonstick coating as well, but I still advise covering them with aluminum foil to reduce the amount of cleanup required later.The trays also stack, to finish. This is a really useful feature that allows us to store three trays in the area of one (really handy for the tight space under the oven).I will most definitely purchase these trays again and am extremely happy with our upgrade to them. If anything changes, I'll update this review.



Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick 21 x 15-Inch Mega Baking Pan Review:


For baking, this pan has been excellent. With simply a massive baking sheet, I can now bake twice as much. One thing I've observed is that, with most regular-sized baking sheets, I also need to rotate the baking sheet halfway through the baking time to try to get uniform doneness throughout all the cookies. Near the edges of the cookies, where some will be done and some will be goopy, you'll probably notice it more. Additionally, if you dare place a second pan in the oven above this one with the heating element on the bottom, it will take a lot longer to bake. Because this sheet is so big, I decided it would be preferable to use it just.


Do you need parchment to bake cookies?

Parchment paper is not a necessary item for baking cookies, but it can be helpful. Parchment paper can prevent cookies from sticking to the baking sheet and making a mess. It can also help to evenly distribute heat, which can result in more consistent baking. If you have parchment paper on hand, it is worth using, but it is not a make-or-break ingredient.

Does the color of a baking sheet matter?

There are a lot of different opinions out there about whether or not the color of a baking sheet matters. Some people say that darker pans absorb more heat, while lighter pans reflect heat better. Others say that it doesn't make a difference at all. So, what's the verdict? Does the color of a baking sheet really matter? It turns out that it depends on what you're baking. If you're baking something that needs to be evenly cooked, like cookies or biscuits, then a dark pan will absorb more heat and could cause the bottoms of your baked goods

How often should you buy new baking sheets?

You should buy new baking sheets when the old ones start to show signs of wear and tear. If they are warped or have deep scratches, it's time to get new ones.

Is it better to bake cookies on foil or parchment paper?

There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on personal preferences. Some people find that cookies baked on foil are crispier, while others prefer the texture of cookies baked on parchment paper. Ultimately, it is up to the baker to decide which method works best for them.

Is it better to grease a cookie sheet or use parchment paper?

There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on personal preferences and what type of cookie sheet you are using. Some people prefer to grease their cookie sheets with butter or cooking spray, while others prefer to use parchment paper. If you are using a dark-colored cookie sheet, you may want to grease it so that the bottoms of the cookies do not burn. If you are using a non-stick cookie sheet, you may not need to grease it at all. Parchment paper can help to prevent sticking and burning, so it is a good option if you are

Is there a difference between cookie sheets and baking sheets?

Cookie sheets and baking sheets are often used interchangeably, but there are some key differences. Cookie sheets have lower sides so that cookies can easily slide off, while baking sheets have higher sides to prevent spills. Cookie sheets are also generally uncoated, while baking sheets are often coated with silicone or another non-stick material.